JLE

Torah Thoughts

Parshat Behar-BeChukotai

 Torah Thoughts

This week we read a double Torah portion, BeHar (Leviticus 25-26:2) and BeChukotai (Leviticus 26:3-27). We conclude the third Book of the Torah, VaYikra (Leviticus).

BeHar contains 57 verses; 7 positive (“do”) commandments and 17 negative (“do not”) commandments.

BeHar opens with a number of laws relating to Eretz Yisrael (the Land of Israel.) The laws of the Sabbatical year and the Jubilee year remind us that the Land of Israel belongs to G-d and that He gave it to His people as a special gift, a Land of faith (see Haftara below.) The Torah continues with social laws protecting the welfare of lower strata of society- the poor and slaves. Our portion concludes a reminder not to worship idols, to observe Shabbat and to revere the Sanctuary.

Haftara

The Haftara (excerpt from the prophets) for the portion of BeHar comes from Jeremiah (32:6-27). The Kingdom of Judah teetered on the edge of the abyss. The Babylonians were poised to conquer the Land and to exile its inhabitants. The prophet Jeremiah had been arrested for warning the people of the impending doom that would result from their flagrant flouting of their covenant with G-d.  Despite the ominous signs and the fact that it was probably not a good time to invest in real-estate in Israel, G-d commanded Jeremiah to purchase and redeem land that belonged to his relative. This echoes one of the topics in our Torah portion- the redemption of land in Israel. Jeremiah’s purchase of land at a time when the Jews were about to be exiled was symbolic of the indomitable optimism that the Jewish People will eventually return to their ancestral homeland. Despite the vicissitudes of our history, we will always remain G-d’s treasured nation and our bond with the Land of Israel can never be broken.

BeChukotai contains 78 verses; 7 positive (“do”) commandments and 5 negative (“do not”) commandments.

The piece below has been adapted from the original essay relating to this week's Torah portion, which was posted under "Torah Thoughts".

Old News

History is a patient and methodical teacher.  She repeats her lessons time and again until even the most recalcitrant of students has grasped the message.  The Jewish People have an existential obligation to be attentive and astute students of history since the message she bears is none other than a measure of our very relationship with G-d.

The Torah portion of BeChukotai lays out the consequences of the Jewish People’s adherence (or lack thereof) to their Covenant with G-d.  The terse list of blessings is followed by a harrowing sequence of curses.  Towards the end of the curses, there appears to be an anomaly.  Chapter 26, verse 39 tells us that the surviving remnant will disintegrate in the lands of their enemies.  The next verse says that they will confess their sin for having betrayed G-d, and for having behaved towards Him with casualness.  One would expect this confession to be the turning point which would restore their relationship with G-d.  Yet, in verse 41, G-d tells them that He will behave toward them with “casualness” and will bring them to the land of their enemies, and perhaps then their unfeeling heart will be humbled and they will gain appeasement for their sin.  Only then will G-d “remember” His covenant with the forefathers and the land.

Why after their confession does G-d wish to continue implementing the curse?

This question bothered many of the classical commentators.  Nachmanides takes a novel approach.  He explains that when G-d responds to their confession with a promise to bring them to the land of their enemies, He is not speaking of the foreign lands of exile, but rather He refers to the Land of Israel.  HaShem will bring the people to the Land after many years of bitter exile.  But the suffering will not be over.  Enemies will dwell in Israel together with the Jewish People.  These adversaries will inflict much hardship and pain.  This will continue until (v. 41) “Their (the Jews’) unfeeling heart will be humbled and then they will gain appeasement for their sin.”  So it seems that G-d acknowledges the suffering in the Diaspora and the recognition of Am Yisrael (the Jewish nation) of their wrongdoing, and rewards it by allowing them to return to their Homeland.  But the process of repentance can only be completed when the Jewish People have humbled their hearts.

Nachmanides explained the above in terms of the destruction of the first Temple and the return from the Babylonian exile.  Nevertheless, as history follows its spiral path, it passes the same points over and over again.  Perhaps we in the modern era have witnessed the recurrence of these events.  Following the Holocaust, the most traumatic event in Jewish history after the destruction of the Temples, G-d has allowed His people to return home.  But the return has not been peaceful.  An implacable enemy had occupied our land during the years in exile.  They refuse to give us a moment’s peace.  There are many among us who have not yet “humbled their hearts.”  There are those who believe that our security lies solely in the hands of the Defense Forces.  Others believe it rests in the mouths of diplomats. Our lack of humility manifests itself on an individual, interpersonal level as well. The social discord and lack of respect for another’s opinion is rending the fabric of our society, leaving room for the enemy to thrust his scimitar deeper into our flesh.

Current events viewed through the Torah’s eternal prism scream their message to the Jewish People loud and clear.  We are at the threshold of Redemption.  We have but one obstacle.  We must develop the humility required to be true servants of HaShem.  Only then will HaShem “remember” His covenant with our forefathers and the Land (verse 42), and the Jewish people will achieve their destiny of serving HaShem at peace in our Land.

Haftara

The Haftara (excerpt from the prophets) for the portion of BeChukotai comes from Jeremiah (16:19-17:14). The prophet rebukes the people for their lack of faith in G-d. How true do his words ring today! The price for not putting our trust in G-d – (17:4) “You will be forced to withdraw from the Heritage (the Land of Israel) I have given you…”  (17:5) “Cursed is the person who trusts in people and makes mortals his source of strength and turns his heart away from G-d.” We see today in Israel, people putting their faith in politicians and statesmen. “The United States will guarantee Israel’s security”, “the international community will protect us if we accede to terrorists’ demands”, people cry, as they demand retreat and appeasement. The prophet reminds us of what history has proven- the Jewish People cannot rely on the goodwill and mellifluous words of anyone else. (17:13) “The hope of Israel is G-d…”

Shabbat Shalom,

Rabbi Baruch Price

Technical Note: Page is suitable to print.